Despite the disappointing box office performance of The Marvels, reports suggest Brie Larson may return as Captain Marvel in the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. This has sparked discussions among fans questioning Marvel Studios’ strategy.
Although many believed Larson was done with the role, new speculations began after she shared an Instagram story (@brielarson) appearing to vote in a Statewide Special Election. Viewers noticed she wore an accessory resembling Carol Danvers’ signature wing, reigniting rumors of her comeback in Avengers: Doomsday.
The decision to bring Larson back, even after The Marvels underperformed, has puzzled audiences. Some see it as favoritism, particularly when comparing her return to the absence of the Eternals cast from upcoming Marvel projects.
Released with a production budget of $200 million and earning around $400 million globally (via The Numbers), Eternals faced harsh reviews and limited audience enthusiasm. The film’s ambitious tone and lack of clear direction contributed to its underwhelming reception.
In an interview with Vanity Fair, director Chloé Zhao reflected on the creative freedom after Endgame, noting it allowed room for experimentation—some of which did not resonate with viewers.
The contrasting treatment of Larson’s Captain Marvel and the sidelined Eternals highlights the inconsistencies in Marvel’s current creative strategy leading into its next major phase.
Author’s Summary: Brie Larson’s rumored return as Captain Marvel in Avengers: Doomsday reignites debate over Marvel’s uneven handling of its heroes after recent box office struggles.