‘All Her Fault’ Review: Sarah Snook, Dakota Fanning and Jake Lacy Anchor Peacock’s Satisfying Domestic Mystery

‘All Her Fault’ Review: Engaging Domestic Mystery Anchored by Strong Cast

Michael Peña stars in this eight-part thriller focused on the disappearance of a 5-year-old boy from a wealthy Chicago neighborhood. Marissa Irvine (Sarah Snook), the desperate mother at the center of Peacock’s All Her Fault, declares,

“We’d do anything for our kids. Anything.”

Her determination captures the lengths a parent might go for their child—no sacrifice is too great to keep her son, missing 5-year-old Milo (Duke McCloud), safe. Yet, the series also explores the limits of parental endurance: the patience worn thin by constant challenges, missed bedtimes due to work, and the harsh truth that no amount of care guarantees a child’s protection forever.

Exploring the Tensions in Parenthood and Mystery

The mystery unfolds within these emotional fissures, showing how Marissa and her husband Peter (Jake Lacy) face the nightmare of Milo’s disappearance from every angle. The show offers clever plot twists and sharp insights into maternal guilt, paternal arrogance, and the delicate boundary between protecting a child and controlling them.

Comparisons and Themes

While it doesn’t fully reach the heights of top domestic thrillers like Big Little Lies, it remains a consistently captivating watch, exploring the complex emotions and conflicts in a wealthy but troubled family.

“For a while, it almost doesn’t seem to matter what really happened to Milo.”
Cast Highlights

The strength of the performances keeps the narrative compelling and grounded, deepening the emotional impact of the unfolding drama.

Author's summary: All Her Fault skillfully blends suspense with intimate family struggles, highlighting the complex sacrifices and tensions behind parental love.

more

The Hollywood Reporter The Hollywood Reporter — 2025-11-05

More News